About Us

“For where two or three gather in my name, there am I with them"
[Matthew 18:20]

Attaining a Church vision is a lifelong process.

Our vision is to:

Go to God in Prayer daily

Spend time daily studying the Bible

Teach People how to become disciples

Be a place to worship God

Support our Church with our prayers, presence, gifts and services

Be a place of spiritual fellowship

Lead many to become mature disciples of Christ

Our Staff:
Pastor Sandi.jpg
Pastor Sandi Dennis-Greenberg

Office Hours: Mondays 5:00-6:30pm



Pastor Sandi grew up in Delphos, OH and attended the University of Northwestern Ohio College. After graduating, she moved to Illinois and worked as a caseworker for The Salvation Army. There she became involved in ministry first leading VBS, then teaching children’s Sunday School and eventually preaching.


The call to ministry that Pastor Sandi felt from an early age became clear and she applied to the seminary in Chicago.  She was accepted with the understanding that she would serve a church as an assistant for up to 2 years before beginning seminary. Pastor Sandi was sent to serve a Salvation Army Church in Waterloo, IA as an assistant to a pastoral couple.  She credits Major and Mrs. Thomas for teaching her so much about the ministry.


Pastor Sandi thoroughly enjoyed her time in seminary and Bible classes were her favorite by far. She also enjoyed Hebrew and Doctrine classes and later studied Hebrew with a reform rabbi to hone her skills. She is currently enrolled in a Course of Study at Methesco in Delaware, Ohio.


In November of 2017 Pastor Sandi began serving Windham UMC. Over that time, she has seen new faces, new decisions for Christ and wonderful spiritual growth and believes that is the biggest blessing a Pastor can have!


Pastor Sandi has been married to husband Joel Greenberg, who is a regional sales representative for Share Corporation, for 10 years. She has one son, Phillip (Nebraska) and two step-sons; Lonnie (New Jersey) and Ethan (University Hts., Ohio). Her family is rounded out by Toby the cat and their two Jack Russell Terriers Bridget and Murphy.


Ministry is Pastor Sandi’s passion! There is nothing she enjoys more than seeing the Word of God come alive in the hearts and minds of God’s people and the changes that come about in their lives because of it!

Rev Rich.jpg
Rev Rich Thewlis



Rev. Rich Thewlis was raised in rural Medina County and is a country boy at heart! He felt God’s call to ministry just one month out of high school in 1977, has been preaching most every Sunday since June of 1981 and became an Ordained Elder in 1987.


After graduating from Baldwin-Wallace College, Rev. Rich began work at the Methodist Theological School in Delaware, Ohio. His main focus was Biblical Studies and languages, both Hebrew and Greek. After seminary graduation in 1985 he moved to Iowa City, IA where he began a PH.D. program in Religion at the Univ of Iowa.


In Iowa, Rev. Rich served the United Church of Christ and although he knew nothing about that denomination, he loved the people of the farm community. Rev. Rich served the United Church of Christ until 1997 when he returned to the United Methodist Church in the East Ohio Conference, happily serving them since.


From 1999-2004, Rev. Rich taught at Baldwin-Wallace College after which he taught at Mallone College in Canton. He began teaching at Hiram College in 2010 where he still teaches part time. While higher education is something that he cherishes and is honored to represent, his first calling is the Church of Jesus Christ.


Rev. Rich met his wife Jill while in college and they have been married for 38 years. Jill is a licensed professional counselor for Coleman Professional Services and they are blessed with two children, David and Sarah, who both live in northeast Ohio, and five grand-cats.


Rev. Rich sees his job at Pastor as being called and trained to shepherd and disciple people but most of all to help individual congregations be the part of the Body of Christ that God needs them to be.


Song Leaders:    


Lay Leader:        

Lay Speakers:    

Pam Montgomery, Blanche Richmond, Jerry Washabaugh, George Montgomery

Vickie Moss, Dee Porter, Shelly Pemberton

Harry Nedelka, Paul Brady

Ruth Randlett

John Patton, Terry Yeager, Paul Brady, Blanch Richmond

Our History:
Old Church Photo.jpg
NUMC Fall Pic.jpg

2020 marks the 206th anniversary of the Nelson United Methodist Church making it the oldest continuously operating church in northeast Ohio.  The church was first organized in 1814 in the home of Isaac Mills who was the brother of one of the original settlers of Nelson Township.  Originally, the church was called the Methodist Episcopal Church and was part of the New Connecticut Circuit.


In 1832, after 18 years of worship in the Mill’s home, the congregation obtained land and made a commitment to build their own church for the convenience of people to attend meetings.  The contract for construction was signed on April 27, 1833 and allowed until September 1, 1833 for completion.  The contractor received $250 for his work, not including materials.  Quite the bargain!  Everything was to be done in “good workmanlike manner.”


We still hold worship service in this same building today.  Of course, there have been quite a few changes over the years.  In 1913, a basement was added to serve as a fellowship hall, new pews were obtained in 1920 and electricity was installed in 1925.  Indoor bathrooms were finally added in 1966 and we got hot water for the first time in 1989!  We also built our first parsonage in 1989 and until that time, the pastor lived with a church member or rented a small room in town.  In 2012 the basement fellowship hall was remodeled and most recently, in 2019, a front porch and awning were added to protect the iconic red front doors.

In 1925, the Congregational Church merged with the Nelson Methodist Episcopal Church.  Later, when the Evangelical United Brethren Church and the Methodist Episcopal Churches merged, many members of the old Silica Sand Church joined our congregation.  In 1968, our name was officially changed to the Nelson United Methodist Church.


Over the 206 years we have been worshiping, the church has been served by 135 pastors.  In July of 2019, Pastor Sandi Dennis-Greenberg, who also serves the Windham United Methodist Church, became our pastor.  Our mission is to serve Christ, to obey the Commandments, to seek and lead others to the saving grace of Jesus Christ and to teach others how to walk in God’s ways.  Please join us in our little church on the circle for Sunday Worship and Fellowship.  Our doors are open and all are welcome!

NUMC Church Front 2020.jpg
Nelson United
Methodist Church

9367 St Rt 305 (on Nelson Circle)

P.O. Box 210

Garrettsville, OH  44231



Sunday Service

Join us for Sunday Service at 9:00am.

Fellowship following service in the church hall.

(Temporarily suspended due to COVID 19)

  • Facebook Social Icon

©2020 by Nelson United Methodist Church